TOTAL 30 vs Biofinity

If you wear contact lenses with a monthly replacement schedule, you've likely come across Biofinity, CooperVision's top-selling monthly replaceable contact lens series. Known for its aspheric optics and Aquaform technology, Biofinity has been a common choice among eye doctors and contact lens wearers since 2007. Alternatively, TOTAL30 is a newer option introduced by Alcon in 2021, introducing innovative lens technologies along with UV blocking. How do these two lenses stack up against each other? Let's delve into a detailed side-by-side comparison of their features and benefits.

Design and Technology

Featuring an aspherical lens design, Biofinity lenses are made of 52% silicone hydrogel Comfilcon A with a 48% water content. They have a center thickness of 0.08 mm at -3.00D and exceptional oxygen transmission at 160 Dk/t, placing them among the top 5 most breathable contact lenses in today's market. Manufacturers of aspherical contact lenses claim that this lens design provides advantages such as improved visual acuity, reduced spherical aberrations, enhanced contrast sensitivity, and better peripheral vision.

Introduced in 2021, the TOTAL30 provides similar oxygen transmission and breathabilty as Biofinity and leverages Alcon's water-gradient technology for outstanding comfort and sustained moisture retention. While its core water content measures only slightly higher at 55% compared to Biofinity's 48%, its surface water content surpasses 90%, making it one of Alcon's key selling points.

Both product lines can correct myopia/hyperopia, age-related presbyopia, and astigmatism. Additionally, Biofinity addresses the needs of presbyopic patients requiring a toric lens, which is not available with the TOTAL30. Lastly, CooperVision offers a screen-optimized version called 'Biofinity Energys' with Digital Zone Optics to meet the demands of those spending extended periods of time in front of screens and phones.

TOTAL3 0 vs Biofinity Families
Product Families TOTAL 30 and CooperVision Biofinity

Moisture Retention and Comfort: MoistureSeal versus Aquaform?

Aquaform is a set of advanced technologies developed by CooperVision, first introduced with the Biofinity lenses in 2007 and now available in CooperVision's Biofinity and MyDay products. Here's what it includes:

  • Special silicone hydrogel-based lens material (Comfilcon A) that allow high levels of oxygen to reach your eyes. Biofinity lenses with this silicone hydrogel material have impressive oxygen transmissibility values of up to 160Dk/t (Comfilcon A) depending on the version and prescription.
  • A unique molecular structure that locks water molecules into the lens, promising to keep both the lenses and your eyes moist.
  • An edge design that prevents excessive rubbing against your eyelids for added comfort and smooth eye lid action.

Celligent, Alcon's technology in TOTAL30 to address comfort and moisture, is based on phosphatidylcholine (PC) and replicates the protective function of epithelial cells and glycocalyx found on the cornea's outermost layer. Celligent uses polymeric nanofibers to attract water molecules while blocking larger, harmful substances like lipids and bacteria. TOTAL30 lenses also feature 'high surface water content', which reaches >90% on the lens's surface and gradually decreases to 50% toward the lens's core.

   Celligent by Alcon    
Celligent by Alcon

Celligent and Aquaform significant innovations in the field of contact lenses. Can we name a winner? No. TOTAL30's phosphatidylcholine-based solution may prove more effective for certain individuals, whereas others might find Biofinity with Aquaform preferable. Moreover, the choice of cleaning solution and rewetting drops greatly influences the comfort of these lenses throughout the day, be it 8, 10, or even 12 hours. TOTAL30 lenses aren't intended for overnight wear during sleep. They must be removed before bedtime and soaked in cleaning solution. Biofinity lenses may be approved for overnight wear by your eye care professional, given their FDA approval for continuous wear. Discuss with your eye care professional which lens is a better fit.

Prescription Parameters

Both TOTAL30 and Biofinity deliver extensive prescription options, catering to individuals ranging from myopia at -12.00 diopters (D) up to hyperopia at +8.00D. This broad spectrum addresses most vision requirements among wearers. Moreover, CooperVision offers the Biofinity XR series that extends these range limits even further. If you need vision correction stronger than -12/+8D, Biofinity is an option, while TOTAL30 won't meet your needs. The Biofinity XR line maintains the quality materials and designs found in standard Biofinity spherical contacts while offering the expanded scope to those requiring extremely strong corrective powers - from extreme nearsightedness (up to -20.00D) through significant farsightedness (up to +20.00D). Furthermore, CooperVision offers a toric multifocal version of Biofinity, a product that Alcon has yet to introduce within the TOTAL30 family.

UV and HEVL Blocking

One difference between TOTAL30 and Biofinity lies in their UV protection1. UV blocking is not available in the Biofinity product line while TOTAL30 are classified as Class 1 UV blockers filtering over 90% of UVA and 99% of UVB light. In addition, TOTAL30 come with some degree of blue-light filtering, a feature that is becoming increasingly popular among contact lens manufacturers.

Cost Comparison

Both monthly replaceable contact lenses provide a very cost-effective alternative to daily disposables. When comparing yearly expenses of the sphere versions, excluding cleaning solutions, TOTAL30 lenses total around $186, while Biofinity lenses come to about $140.

TOTAL30 vs Biofinity: Side-by-Side Specs

TOTAL30

Biofinity

Product Image Total30 Biofinity
Price Comparison

Lowest prices found:

6 Pack: $62.04

12 Pack: $115.59

Lowest price found:

6 Pack: $47.59

Manufacturer Alcon Inc. CooperVision, Inc.
part of
The Cooper Companies Inc.
Release Date September 2021 (US)
2007
Prescription Parameters
Replacement Schedule Monthly Monthly
Wearing Details info Daily wear Daily wear or
up to 6 nights or
7 days extended wear
Sphere Powers -12.00D to -8.00D in 0.50 steps
-8.00D to +6.00D in 0.25 steps
-6.00D to +8.00D in 0.5 steps
-12.00D to +8.00D
(in 0.5 steps after +-6.00D)
Base Curves info 8.4 mm 8.6 mm
Diameters 14.2 mm 14.0 mm
Technical Parameters
FDA Group info V-B V
Lens Material Silicone hydrogel
(Lehfilcon A)
Silicone hydrogel
(Comfilcon A)
Lens Design Spherical Aspherical
Wetting Agents info Yes
PC (phosphoryl choline)
None
% of Material 45% 52%
Water Content 55% 48%
Center Thickness info 0.08 mm 0.08 mm
Oxygen Transmissibility info 154 Dk/t 160 Dk/t
Modulus info 0.6 MPa 0.75 MPa
Refractive Index info 1.4 1.4
Other Features
Special Features info
  • Biomimetic CELLIGENT Technology supports resist bacteria and lipid deposits.
  • Water gradient technology with high water content (>90%) at the outermost surface.
UV Blocking info Class 1
>90% UVA
>99% UVB

HEVL filtration
No
Dynamic Light Absorption info No No
Visibility Tint Yes
Light blue-green (Reactive Blue 247) to make it easier to see while handling.
Yes
(Sofblue®)
Inside-out Mark No No
Packaging, Pricing and Offers
Packaging Details 6 lenses per box
in sealed blister packs containing isotonic phosphate buffered saline solution (PBS) with polymeric wetting agents.
6 lenses per box,
immersed in buffered 0.83% saline
Price Range info $62 - $75 (6 lenses)
$116 - $146 (12 lenses)
$48 - $66 (6 lenses)
Cost per Day info $0.34 - $0.42 (6 lenses)
$0.32 - $0.41 (12 lenses)
$0.26 - $0.37 (6 lenses)
Online Retailers info
Compare Prices


Special Deals

Compare Prices


Additional Notes

1 TOTAL30 contact lenses with UV filtering are not a substitute for sunglasses.