TOTAL30 vs ACUVUE OASYS

ACUVUE OASYS has remained a top performer for almost two decades, establishing itself as one of the most successful contact lenses on the market. TOTAL 30, a newer contender in the field of monthly/bi-weekly replaceable lenses, belongs to the latest generation of silicone hydrogel contact lenses. Could it challenge ACUVUE OASYS's reign at the top? Explore the differences and advantages of each lens in our detailed comparison.

Design and Technology

TOTAL30 lenses, launched in 2021, are monthly disposable lenses that feature Alcon's CELLIGENT Technology. TOTAL30 lenses are composed of 45% material, boast a high water content of 55%, have a center thickness of 0.08 mm, and offer superior oxygen transmission at 154 Dk/t, ranking among the best in the lens market today.

Introduced in 2005, the slightly thinner bi-weekly ACUVUE OASYS utilizes Johnson & Johnson's HYDRACLEAR PLUS technology - a source of continuous moisture retention. While its water content is lower compared to TOTAL30 (38% versus 55%), the oxygen transmissibility of both lenses is beyond the 140 Dk/t mark.

Moisture Retention: Celligent vs Hydraclear Plus

Wearer comfort and dryness are top concerns for manufacturers developing new contact lens products. In the case of ACUVUE OASYS, Johnson & Johnson is incorporating a polyvinylpyrrolidone-based wetting agent into the lens material. This technology - called HYDRACLEAR - effectively attracts and retains water molecules by binding the silicone polymers and long-chain water-loving molecules.

Celligent, the wetting technology used in the TOTAL30 lenses is based on phosphatidylcholine (PC) and replicates the protective function of epithelial cells and glycocalyx found on the cornea's outermost layer. This technology uses polymeric nanofibers to attract water molecules while blocking larger, harmful substances like lipids and bacteria. Alcon also boasts what they call 'high surface water content', which reaches >90% on the lens's surface and gradually decreases to 50% toward the lens's core.

   Celligent by Alcon    
Celligent by Alcon

Both wetting technologies represent remarkable advancements in the field of contact lenses. It would be unfair to favor one over the other. Ultimately, Alcon's phosphatidylcholine-based solution may work better for some individuals, while others may prefer the PVP-based Hydraclear. Furthermore, the choice of cleaning solution significantly impacts how comfortable these lenses feel after wearing them for 6, 8, or even 10 hours.

Prescription Parameters

There are no surprises when looking at the available power ranges. OASYS and TOTAL30 cover prescriptions from -12.00D to +8.00D, meeting the correction requirements of the majority of patients. However, it should be noted that ACUVUE OASYS is available in two base curves (8.4mm and 8.8mm), providing eye doctors two options in the fitting process. TOTAL30, on the other hand, comes with an 8.6mm base curve.

UV and HEVL Blocking

Both ACUVUE OASYS and TOTAL30 provide outstanding UV protection1, significantly minimizing your pupil's exposure to UVA and UVB radiation. These lenses are designated as Class 1 UV blockers, filtering over 90% of UVA and 99% of UVB light. Furthermore, both lenses incorporate some degree of blue-light filtering, a feature that is becoming increasingly popular among contact lens manufacturers.

Cost Comparison

To compare the cost between TOTAL30 and ACUVUE OASYS, it's important to note that OASYS is a bi-weekly lens, which means you need to purchase twice as many 6-pack boxes for an equivalent semi-annual or annual supply. TOTAL30 lenses start at $186 for a 12-month supply (for one eye), whereas OASYS lenses cost more than $250. This translates into a 35% price advantage for TOTAL30. You may want to mention this when discussing your options with your eye care professional. However, remember that an eye care professional will determine the prescription parameters, including base curve, diameters, prescription parameters, and other factors, which influence the choice between the two lenses.

TOTAL30 vs ACUVUE OASYS: Side-by-Side Specs

TOTAL30

ACUVUE® OASYS

Product Image Total30 Acuvue Oasys
Price Comparison

Lowest prices found:

6 Pack: $62.04

12 Pack: $115.59

Lowest prices found:

12 Pack: $79.04

24 Pack: $152.99

Manufacturer Alcon Inc. Johnson & Johnson Vision Care, Inc.
Release Date September 2021 (US)
2005
Prescription Parameters
Replacement Schedule Monthly Two weeks
Wearing Details info Daily wear Daily wear or
up to 6 consecutive nights extended wear
Sphere Powers -12.00D to -8.00D in 0.50 steps
-8.00D to +6.00D in 0.25 steps
-6.00D to +8.00D in 0.5 steps
-12.00D to -6.00D in 0.5 steps
-6.00D to +6.00D in 0.25 steps
+6.00D to +8.00D in 0.5 steps
Base Curves info 8.4 mm 8.4 mm
8.8 mm
Diameters 14.2 mm 14.0 mm
Technical Parameters
FDA Group info V-B V
Lens Material Silicone hydrogel
(Lehfilcon A)
Silicone hydrogel
(Senofilcon A)
Lens Design Spherical Spherical
Wetting Agents info Yes
PC (phosphoryl choline)
Yes
- PVP
% of Material 45% 62%
Water Content 55% 38%
Center Thickness info 0.08 mm 0.07 mm
Oxygen Transmissibility info 154 Dk/t 147 Dk/t
Modulus info 0.6 MPa 0.7 MPa
Refractive Index info 1.4 1.42
Other Features
Special Features info
  • Biomimetic CELLIGENT Technology supports resist bacteria and lipid deposits.
  • Water gradient technology with high water content (>90%) at the outermost surface.
UV Blocking info Class 1
>90% UVA
>99% UVB

HEVL filtration
Class 1
96% UVA
99% UVB
Dynamic Light Absorption info No No
Visibility Tint Yes
Light blue-green (Reactive Blue 247) to make it easier to see while handling.
Yes
(blue)
Inside-out Mark No Yes
(123)
Packaging, Pricing and Offers
Packaging Details 6 lenses per box
in sealed blister packs containing isotonic phosphate buffered saline solution (PBS) with polymeric wetting agents.
6 lenses per box,
each lens in a foil-sealed plastic package
Price Range info $62 - $75 (6 lenses)
$116 - $146 (12 lenses)
$79 - $103 (12 lenses)
$153 - $202 (24 lenses)
Cost per Day info $0.34 - $0.42 (6 lenses)
$0.32 - $0.41 (12 lenses)
$0.47 - $0.61 (12 lenses)
$0.46 - $0.60 (24 lenses)
Online Retailers info
Compare Prices


Special Deals

Compare Prices


Additional Notes

1 Contact Lenses with UV filtering are not a substitute for sunglasses.