Comparison of ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-DAY and DAILIES TOTAL1

In our article about the most advanced daily contact lenses, we've already examined the top four options. This article now delves into an in-depth comparison between two of them: DAILIES TOTAL1 and ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day. These lenses offer wearers the latest innovations in contact lens technology, ensuring improved comfort and visual performance. Within this comprehensive analysis, we will look at the features, specifications, and benefits of each lens, preparing you for an informed discussion with your eye care professional.

Design and Technology

Introduced in 2022, ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day utilizes Johnson & Johnson's innovative TearStable Technology to enhance comfort and reduce tear evaporation. The lens incorporates a spherical design, employs Johnson & Johnson's renowned silicone hydrogel material, Senofilcon A and includes UV and HEVL blocking ingredients to protect your eyes from harmful rays.

Much like the OASYS MAX 1-Day, the DAILIES TOTAL1, which has been in around for over a decade, employs a spherical lens design utilizing Alcon's silicone hydrogel material, Delefilcon A. This, coupled with their SmarTears Technology in a high-precision production process, seeks to attain an optimal balance between water content and breathability, resulting in exceptional, all-day comfort.

Material, Parameters & Special Features

Moisture Retention, Breathability and Comfort

Both lenses fall under the FDA's hydrogel classification and are designated as V-C lenses, indicating highly breathable sicilone hydrogel material with water content of up to 50%.

Alcon and Johnson & Johnson prioritize wearer comfort and address concerns related to contact lens dryness. TearStable Technology which is exclusively available with the ACUVUE OASYS MAX, enhances comfort by significantly reducing tear evaporation. This is achieved by utilizing a high-molecular-weight polyvinylpyrrolidone based wetting agent (PVP). It mimics the natural eye component mucin and evenly spreads water and lipid components of the tear film, providing superior moisture retention. Tearstable also combines PVP with a self-hydrating silicone monomer for biocompatibility, and improved tear film stability.

Alcon's approach is different. The wetting agent used in the DAILIES TOTAL1 lenses is phosphatidylcholine (PC), which mimics natural tears and, similar to the OASYS MAX, stabilizes the lipid tear film. Alcon also boasts what they call 'high surface water content,' which reaches around 80% on the lens's surface and gradually decreases to 50% toward the lens's core.

Another crucial factor in contact lens comfort is oxygen transmission: DAILIES TOTAL1 and ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day both offer high oxygen transmissibility with a Dk/t value of 121 for the OASYS MAX and an impressive 156 Dk/t for the TOTAL1. This high oxygen transmissibility, paired with their moisture retention technologies TearStable and SmarTears, supports corneal health and ensures comfort throughout the day.

Prescription Parameters

Both lenses cover typical power ranges from -12.00D to +8.00D for the OASYS and -12.00D to +6.00D for the TOTAL1. It's worth noting that both lenses feature a base curve of 8.5 mm, a parameter determined by your eye doctor when prescribing them. Additionally, the OASYS MAX offers an alternative base curve of 9.0 mm, providing an option that the TOTAL1 does not have.

UV and HEVL Protection

ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day lenses offer exceptional UV protection, effectively reducing your exposure to harmful UVA and UVB radiation. These lenses are classified as Class 1 UV blockers, with the ability to filter more than 90% of UVA and 99% of UVB light. What sets them apart is their comprehensive protection, providing not only UV shielding but also blue-light filtering (called OptiBlue). Alcon did not include UV or HEVL blocking in their TOTAL1 product line and if you're looking for Alcon lenses with UV blocking, consider their PRECISION1 daily lenses. It's crucial to remember that while these lenses provide significant UV protection, they are not a complete substitute for UV-absorbing eyewear. Contact lenses only cover a small area around the pupil, so it's still essential to complement your eye protection with appropriate UV-absorbing sunglasses or eyewear for comprehensive safeguarding against harmful UV rays.

Oxygen Transmission and Water Content

Oxygen transmission is crucial for maintaining healthy eyes during contact lens wear. DAILIES TOTAL1 and ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day both offer high oxygen transmissibility with a Dk/t value in the 120-140 range. Exceptional oxygen transmissibility paired with a high water content (38% for the OASYS MAX and 55% for the INFUSE) support optimal corneal health and comfort throughout the day.

Cost Comparison

DAILIES TOTAL1 and ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day Multifocal contact lenses can be acquired from eye care professionals or various online contact lens vendors. While prices fluctuate, it's clear that the OASYS MAX tends to be 15% more expensive than the DAILIES TOTAL1. As of Nov 2023, a 90-pack of ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-DAY is priced at approximately $100, whereas DAILIES TOTAL1 is available for around $86. This translates to an annual supply price difference of about $120.

ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day and DAILIES TOTAL 1: Specs Side-by-Side

ACUVUE® OASYS MAX 1-DAY

DAILIES TOTAL1

Product Image ACUVUE OASYS MAX 1-Day Dailies Total1
Price Comparison

Lowest prices found:

30 Pack: $56.94

90 Pack: $113.04

Lowest prices found:

30 Pack: $43.19

90 Pack: $99.44

Manufacturer Johnson & Johnson Vision Care, Inc. Alcon Inc.
Release Date September 2022 2013
Prescription Parameters
Replacement Schedule Daily Daily
Wearing Details info Daily wear Daily wear
Sphere Powers -12.00D to +8.00D in 0.25 steps
and in 0.5 steps after +-6.00D
-12.00D to -6.00D in 0.50 steps
-6.00D to +6.00D in 0.25 steps
Base Curves info 8.5 mm
9.0 mm
8.5 mm
Diameters 14.3 mm 14.1 mm
Technical Parameters
FDA Group info V-C V-C
Lens Material Silicone hydrogel
(Senofilcon A)
Silicone hydrogel
(Delefilcon A)
Lens Design Spherical Spherical
Wetting Agents info Yes
- PVP
Yes
- PC
% of Material 62% 67%
Water Content 38% 33%
Center Thickness info 0.085 mm 0.09 mm
Oxygen Transmissibility info 121 Dk/t 156 Dk/t
Modulus info - 0.7 MPa
Refractive Index info 1.42 1.42
Other Features
Special Features info
UV Blocking info Class 1
99.9% UVA
Up to 100% UVB
No
Dynamic Light Absorption info No No
Visibility Tint Yes Yes
Light Blue
(VISITINT®)
Inside-out Mark Yes
123 mark
Unknown
Packaging, Pricing and Offers
Packaging Details 30 or 90 lenses per box,
each lens in a foil-sealed plastic package. 90 lenses per box not available for base curve 9.0mm.
30 lenses per box or
90 lenses per box
in buffered saline with polymeric wetting agents
Price Range info $57 - $74 (30 lenses)
$113 - $146 (90 lenses)
$43 - $60 (30 lenses)
$99 - $140 (90 lenses)
Cost per Day info $1.90 - $2.47 (30 lenses)
$1.26 - $1.62 (90 lenses)
$1.44 - $2.00 (30 lenses)
$1.10 - $1.56 (90 lenses)
Online Retailers info
Special Deals

Compare Prices


Special Deals

Compare Prices